March 21, 2005
A quote that connects to the Nietzsche/Heidegger idea of viewpoint:
"What has emerged from this critical posture toward beginnings [by postmodernism] is an awareness about the significance of what I will call "points of entry"--those interpretational thresholds which allow us to enter into a dialogue with a text, a thinker, or a tradition. Points of entry frame the possibilities of all interpretation; they open up pathways for discovery even as they close off other venues and approaches. Entering into a thinker's work from a certain vantage point determines much about how an interpreter will frame her questions and follow her path of inquiry."
The quote is from a review by Charles Bambach of Arendt and Heidegger:The Fate of the Political by Dana Villa in the Winter 1998 issue of Negations.
|
I wonder whether it is true that "Points of entry frame the possibilities of all interpretation; they open up pathways for discovery even as they close off other venues and approaches. Entering into a thinker's work from a certain vantage point determines much about how an interpreter will frame her questions and follow her path of inquiry."
If two people have the same institutional point of entry --two academics studying a text, two students listening to a lecture about a text, two unconnected borrowers from a public library of a text -- it seems to me that there will be certain stylistic similarities between the trajectory of their interpretations of the text -- the students might read the text to answer questions about it on a class quiz, the academics might read it as a possible topic for a paper, the two library patrons might read it "rawly", without the state of the art critical paraphernalia of the academics, or -- derivatively, via the teacher -- the students. But the movement within the texts can vary quite a bit, and I am not sure if there isn't a "revenge" of the text on the framing interpretation -- a moment that is not controlled by the point of entry. Or at least, it strikes me that is the possibility that makes a text "textual".